1. How many people do you cook for?
What to decide: Size is the first and most important choice.
How to choose: Catalog listings describe a 4-quart basket as about 2 to 3 servings, and a 5 to 5.5-quart basket as about 3 to 4 or more. If you cook for four or more, or you want leftovers, look at 5 quarts and up, or an oven-style unit.
2. Basket or oven style?
What to decide: The shape changes what you can cook.
How to choose: A basket cooks small batches fast and takes little space. An oven-style air fryer (a toaster oven with an air fry mode) fits a pizza, a sheet of fries or a whole chicken, but it is bigger and heavier.
3. Think about what you cook most
What to decide: Wings and fries need space to crisp.
How to choose: Food crisps when air can move around it, so a crowded basket cooks unevenly. If you cook a lot of wings, tenders or fries, size up, and shake or flip halfway.

4. Check the temperature range
What to decide: Some units stop at 400°F and others go higher.
How to choose: A higher maximum can give a crispier finish on frozen foods, though most everyday cooking works at 400°F or lower. Check the listing for the range.
5. Counter space and weight
What to decide: An air fryer you cannot leave out is an air fryer you stop using.
How to choose: Measure your counter and the cabinet height. A basket model is easier to store, and a large oven is easier to leave on the counter.
6. Cleanup matters
What to decide: A dishwasher-safe basket makes it easy to use every week.
How to choose: Check that the basket and crisper plate are dishwasher-safe, and think about how deep and hard to reach the corners are.
Six popular models to compare
Ninja AF101 Air Fryer
A 4-quart basket model with simple dials and dishwasher-safe parts, a good fit for couples and beginners. The basket shape is not ideal for a whole chicken.
$$ Mid-range · 4.7★ (90 473)
Instant Vortex Plus Air Fryer (4 qt)
A 4-quart basket model with touch controls and a quick preheat, suited to small kitchens. It has fewer functions than some rivals.
$ Budget · 4.6★ (32 100)
Ninja Air Fryer Pro 5 Qt (5-in-1, AF142)
A 5-quart basket for families of three to five, with five functions including reheat and dehydrate. Its maximum is 400°F.
$$$ Premium · 4.7★ (3 129)
Ninja Air Fryer Max XL (AF161)
A 5.5-quart basket with a 450°F Max Crisp mode and a broil rack, good for bigger batches and frozen foods. It takes more counter space.
$$$ Premium · 4.6★ (28 000)
Cuisinart TOA-65NAS Air Fryer Toaster Oven
A convection toaster oven with a real air fry mode that fits a 12-inch pizza, useful when you want one appliance to bake and air fry. The dials are less precise than digital controls.
$ Budget · 4.6★ (28 400)
Ninja Double Oven Pro Smart XL
A large double oven (30.2 quarts) that fits a 4.5 lb chicken and cooks two dishes at two temperatures, for larger households. It is expensive and has a big footprint.
$$$ Premium · 4.7★ (16 800)
Some links on this page are affiliate links.
Images are for illustrative purposes only. Real product images are on Amazon.
Put it to work
These pages help you cook with the air fryer you choose:
- Air fryer cooking times chart: times and temperatures for common foods.
- Air fryer chicken tenders: our most-searched air fryer recipe.
- Air fryer chicken breast: how to keep it juicy.
- Air fryer Thanksgiving sides: sides that free up the oven.
- Best air fryers under $100: our budget roundup.
